In a previous posting, I introduced you to Collanos Workplace and told you how great the collaboration software is, especially for use with distance teaching and learning projects. I have used it successfully with both undergraduate and graduate students. For example, during Winter Quarter 2010, I used Collanos Workplace to guide five grad students through independent study projects. Collanos Workplace made it easy to communicate with students and keep the whole process under control. In a nutshell, I felt that Collanos Workplace was a great collaboration tool!
No more. Unfortunately, something has gone awry with Collanos Workplace. It is no longer reliable. One moment the Collanos screen indicates that I am online and connected to the Collanos system. The next moment it indicates that I am offline. So far during this Fall Quarter 2010, Collanos Workplace has been up and down like a yo-yo on a string! When it works, it’s great. It’s the rest of the time that has soured me on Collanos Workplace.
I emailed Collanos Workplace tech support several times about the problems my students and I are encountering with connecting to the Collanos system. NO ONE appears to be either monitoring the Collanos system or responding to support questions.
I understand that Collanos Workplace is available as free software. However, the company’s unwillingness to respond to support questions or to at least keep users aware of system problems and corrective actions being taken is unacceptable. Collanos, like many software developers and hosted services, seems to have adopted the industry practice of hiding behind its website and ignoring user requests for help. This is truly unfortunate.
Collanos Workplace WAS a great collaboration software tool. It could still be a great tool IF Collanos would pay attention to its software.
I do not write negative comments about software tools very often. However, this time I am truly disappointed in what has happened to Collanos Workplace software. I hate to lose a great software tool. Collanos Workplace software will be remembered.
Rick Lillie (CalState, San Bernardino)

Collanos Workplace Tombstone
EPILOGUE (11/13/10)
After days (even weeks) of not being able to “connect” to Collanos Workplace, suddenly it connects! Collanos is NOT known for paying attention to its users (i.e., by email or postings to forums). Of all the software developers that I have experienced over the years, Collanos is one of the most arrogant. Noting that Collanos Workplace now seems to be back up and “connecting,” I checked the Collanos forum to see if there was a posting that explained the resurrection of Collanos Workplace from the dead.
Below is a screenshot of the notice posted November 8, 2010 by the Collanos CEO. What an attitude. No apology. No we’re sorry for the inconvenience. No apology for being silent for so long.
Based on its history, think twice before using Collanos Workplace again! To bad. Collanos Workplace is damn good software (when it works and the company pays attention to its product and support).
EPILOGUE (11/15/10)
I monitored Collanos Workplace for the past couple of days. After months of sporadic performance, it finally works! Apparently, Helfenstein (and his staff) discovered the problem(s) with communication servers and fixed them. Congratulations!
While I am happy to see Collanos Workplace working again, I am not willing to accept the half-assed technical support provided by Collanos. For months, no one would respond to postings from users complaining about the sporadic, poor performance of Collanos Workplace. Silence on the part of Collanos is not golden. Silence represents total disrespect for users of Collanos Workplace.
While I like Collanos Workplace, and believe it may be better than Groove, I am leery about trusting Collanos and its willingness to stand behind its products and service.
EPILOGUE (12/05/2010)
I have been testing Collanos Workplace almost on a daily basis since November 15, 2010 (see above comment). Each time I log into Collanos Workplace, connection to the servers happens almost immediately. This is the best it has worked throughout all of 2010. It looks like Collanos Workplace is working again. I will probably take a chance during my upcoming Winter Quarter 2011 classes and use Collanos Workplace with graduate students doing independent study projects. However, I remain skeptical about Collanos Workplace. It is incredible software.
It’s the silence from Collanos Software that makes me uneasy about the company. Comments posted to the Collanos discussion board are mostly old and outdated. The last posting from Peter Helfenstein, CEO of Collanos Software was November 8, 2010. Since then, there’s been absolutely nothing said by anyone from Collanos Software that I can find on the Collanos discussion board.
Does this seem like a good way to run an organization to you?
Rick Lillie (CalState, San Bernardino)
